In the blockchain space, the balance between rapid innovation and stability has always been a contentious one. While the industry leader, Ethereum, has established itself as a beacon of rigorous, research-driven development, other networks like Solana have embarked on a path characterized by aggressive iteration, fast-paced growth and more than a couple of black eyes on the way. This distinction underpins a broader conversation within the blockchain community (that most outsiders don’t often get to see) regarding the “optimal” approach to innovation. Through an exploration of recent events and technical hurdles within the Solana ecosystem, this analysis aims to shed light on the complexities and trade-offs inherent in the network's strategy, without casting a value judgment on any one approach.

Understanding Solana's Network Challenges

At the heart of Solana's recent challenges are transaction failures, which can be categorized into three types: (1) successful transactions, (2) executed but failed transactions, and (3) dropped transactions.

1. Successful Transactions

The first category, as one might expect, is exactly what everyone wants to see. These are transactions that are submitted to and processed by the network where the desired outcome is achieved. yay 🎉

2. Executed but Failed Transactions

The second category, executed but failed transactions, might sound problematic on it’s face, but as a matter of fact, these transactions are also working exactly as intended. Transactions that fall into this bucket are transactions break some rule of either the network or the smart contracts they’re using. The most common example of this is “Slippage Exceeded” or said differently, due to the execution of already queued transactions, the value of an asset moved out of the desired price range before your transaction was able to be executed causing it to be intentionally dropped. This is extremely common with bots seeking arbitrage opportunities on low-liquidity meme coins like the kind we’re seeing a lot more of on the Solana network lately. Interestingly, the Solana network has been operating without degradation to user experience with around 50%+ of transactions failing since around November of 2023. This is because the vast majority of transactions that fail are made by bots and not users and this has not changed.

Source: dune.com | Failed transaction rate chart showing ~50%+ transaction failure for months

Source: dune.com | Failed transaction rate chart showing ~50%+ transaction failure for months

Source: X.com | Blockspace waste chart showing failure rate of arbitrage transactions

Source: X.com | Blockspace waste chart showing failure rate of arbitrage transactions

3. Dropped Transactions

The third category, dropped transactions, has been particularly problematic as of late, causing significant service degradation on the Solana network for regular users like myself. From the recent meme coin mania, to the transaction intensive proof-of-work mining application “Ore” that recently debuted on the network, there is a lot of demand for Solana blockspace these days. With current transactions exceeding over 1,000 per second, the cracks in the implementation have begun to become more apparent.

Source: X.com | Founder of Ore providing perspective on TPS milestone made on popular Ethereum Layer 2, Base.

Source: X.com | Founder of Ore providing perspective on TPS milestone made on popular Ethereum Layer 2, Base.

Source: Solana FM Block Explorer | Included in this count are only successful transactions and executed but failed transactions; this number does not include dropped transactions or “vote transactions” that are sometimes included in these data.

Source: Solana FM Block Explorer | Included in this count are only successful transactions and executed but failed transactions; this number does not include dropped transactions or “vote transactions” that are sometimes included in these data.

Liveness vs Safety Faults

Ultimately, these dropped transactions result from networking layer issues, rather than problems with consensus or execution. This means that, while users are currently facing degradation or even full interruption of their access to the network (often referred to as a “Liveness Failure”), there have been no issues relating to unauthorized movement of assets (often referred to as “Safety Failure”). This isn’t to trivialize the faults in liveness; the Solana network has experienced it’s fair share of these events in it’s short 4 year history, often relating to the same type of overwhelming to the network uniquely enabled by the low fee environment, the point is only to draw the distinction between the two types of failures. As a matter of fact, liveness failures often lead to countless instances of opportunity cost for those who otherwise can’t get the current block leader to pick up a transaction they will benefit from, or even worse, liquidation for a leveraged trader who is unable to add additional collateral or close their at-risk positions.

Untitled

Source: Solana Status Page | Example of the worst month in Solana’s history

Source: Solana Status Page | Example of the worst month in Solana’s history